The restaurant at 100 Mountain Road on Mount Tom was listed at $995,000. It sold on Sept. 9, 2026, for $475,000. Kevin Perrier and Volkan Polatol bought it. Paul Gallagher, the broker on the deal, estimated that the condominiums the partners are considering for the site would need asking prices of about $1 million each to recoup the cost of developing it, MassLive reported.
So the site lost more than half its asking price as a restaurant, and its future value depends on a price that only three Easthampton home sales have reached this year. If you're comparing Easthampton with its neighbors at the upper end of your budget, the gap between those two numbers shows you where the town's ceiling sits right now.
A century of roadside business on Mount Tom
The building has stood on the mountain for more than a century. In the 1920s it was the Green Candle Inn, a stop for travelers on the dirt road over Mount Tom. In the 1940s it became The Old Mill, a sandwich shop that used the building's wooden windmill for power. Later it was Harvest Valley. Then it became Tavern on the Hill, the name the Daily Hampshire Gazette used when it called the place the city's most scenic dining destination. Amy and Lawrence "Larry" Guyette opened Tavern on the Hill in 2005. It was known for barbecue, and it reopened after a fire in 2022.
The sale price came out of a search for a restaurant buyer that never found one. MassLive reported that the property had been on the market off and on for years without interest from a restaurant operator. Gallagher cold-called restaurateurs, and he said the industry veterans he reached were "standing pat." "Bars and restaurants are struggling tremendously," he told the Gazette, and he added that he had approached several "major players" in the area restaurant business without getting any bites.
The buyers have been clear about the next use. "It's not going to be another restaurant," Polatol told MassLive. "The restaurant business is tough." Polatol owns Mulino's and Bishop's Lounge in Northampton. Perrier is president of Five Star Building Corp. Polatol said plans were still in flux, that the open questions were how many units to build and how to place them on a mountaintop with difficult topography, and that the partners are in no hurry. He also said that bringing the old building up to current codes would pretty much require a new building.
The $475,000 bought a 1.5-acre site, mostly in Easthampton with a sliver in Holyoke, and a view across the valley. "And you are getting a million-dollar view," Gallagher said of the condos. Whether that view sells for a million dollars in Easthampton is the open question.
Where Easthampton home prices topped out in 2026
The Gazette prints weekly lists of recorded deed transfers for Hampshire County towns. In 2026, three Easthampton home sales in those lists reached $1 million or more: $1,299,000 in the July 10 list, $1,000,000 in the Nov. 6 list and $999,500 in the June 12 list.
Below those three, prices thin out quickly. Three more homes sold between $850,000 and $880,000, recorded in the June 12, July 10 and Aug. 28 lists, and one sold for $805,000 in the July 10 list. The next group sits in the $700,000s, with sales of $799,000 in the Aug. 14 list, $790,000 in the Aug. 21 list and $735,000 in the Jan. 30 list. A more typical week looks like the Sept. 4 list, where eight Easthampton transfers ran from $245,000 to $659,900, and most fell between about $515,000 and $611,000.
Easthampton's other seven-figure transfers this year were commercial or land deals. Among them were 179 Northampton St. at $1,950,000 in the April 17 list, 97 Union St. at $1,865,000 in the July 17 list, and 385 Main St. at $1,300,000 to Tcb 385 Main LLC in the Aug. 7 list. The 385 Main St. parcel is the 53-acre riverside site in the Growing Green project. The Community Builders plans 87 affordable rental units there, and most of the land will be preserved, the Gazette reported.
Condos asking about $1 million on Mount Tom would be priced alongside the three highest home sales Easthampton has recorded this year. Each of those was one house, and a condo development would need several buyers at that level.
New construction is pricing in the high $600s
Easthampton's newest single-family homes give a closer read on what buyers pay for new construction. CTW Enterprises Inc. sold three new homes on Elizabeth Lane this year, for $669,900 in the Aug. 14 list, $659,900 in the Sept. 4 list and $729,900 in the Sept. 25 list. In April, Lazy D Construction LLC sold a property on Glen Cove Place for $750,000, according to the April 10 list.
On those numbers, a new-construction buyer in Easthampton this year paid in the high $600s to the low $700s. A $1 million condo would cost roughly $270,000 to $340,000 more than a new single-family home in town. That difference is the price of the view and the location on the mountain.
The same partners are already selling homes downtown
Perrier and Polatol have a project underway in town. In early 2025 they bought the former Notre Dame du Bon Conseil Church campus at 35 Pleasant St., about 9 acres, from the Diocese of Springfield for $825,000, MassLive reported. The church was built in 1922 and closed in 2010, when three Easthampton parishes merged into Our Lady of the Valley Parish.
The project is called Riverview Place. The Planning Board approved the first phase's special permit on Sept. 23, 2025, and the Gazette described the plan in phases. The first phase is 10 market-rate homes in two buildings beside the church. The second turns the church into nine homes, one of them using the bell tower. Later phases replace the rectory and the daycare building with new buildings. In mid-September, Polatol told MassLive that site work on the first 10 units was wrapping up, that six of them had sold, and that work inside the church would begin soon on the way to 41 homes in total.
"We hope we do the same at the tavern, something that Easthampton and the community can be proud of," Polatol said in the same MassLive interview. The church campus is a walkable downtown site. The mountain site has to find buyers who will pay for the view and accept the drive. Polatol described that drive in plain terms: "I think that location is great in summertime. But it's very challenging in winter."
What this means if you're shopping or selling near the top
For a buyer comparing towns, Easthampton's upper tier is short. Six recorded home sales this year came in at or above $850,000, so a listing priced in that range has very few local sales to compare it with. When a seller at that level names a price, ask which sales support it. The answer may be one or two Easthampton homes, plus sales from Northampton or the hill towns.
For an owner of one of the larger homes in town, the same short list works in the other direction. The three sales at or above $1 million show that the price can happen here. They also show how rarely it has happened. Pricing a house near that level depends on how it compares with those few sales in setting, size and condition, more than on the citywide trend. Our August look at Easthampton's two-speed market explains why a single citywide median says little about either end of the range.
The partners have not yet decided how many homes the Mount Tom site will hold. They have said they are in no hurry, so the first real test of whether a view on Mount Tom adds hundreds of thousands of dollars to an Easthampton home will come when those condos are listed.
If you're weighing an Easthampton home in the $700,000 to $1 million range, or wondering where your own house falls among this year's recorded sales, Shelly Hardy can go through the comparable sales with you. Schedule a free consultation, or start with an instant home valuation and we'll look at the numbers together.